In this Insta360 X5 review, we dive deep into whether this new 360 camera truly lives up to the expectations set by its predecessors. With extensive side-by-side testing against the X4, Qoocam 3 Ultra, and even the iPhone 16 Pro, we explore image quality, stabilization, low-light performance, and more to determine if the upgrade is worth your investment.
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- Stabilization Showdown – Drone, Fast Motion, and Horizon Lock
- Audio Test – New Steel Mesh Wind Guard vs Ambient Noise
- Lens Replacement Kit – Anti-Scratch Glass and Field Repairs
- Software Update Review – New Features in Insta360 Studio
- 360 Video Editing for Vision Pro – Immersive Video Export Made Easy
- Final Verdict – The Truth Behind the Hype
- FAQ
Introduction
The Insta360 X5 has generated considerable buzz in the 360 camera community. But does it truly live up to the hype? In this detailed review, we will explore the X5’s performance in various real-world scenarios, comparing it against its predecessors—the X4 and Qoocam 3 Ultra—as well as the iPhone 16 Pro. From image quality to low-light performance, we’ll dissect every aspect to help you determine if this camera is worth your investment.
Image Quality Comparison (X5 vs X4 vs Qoocam 3 Ultra vs iPhone 16 Pro)
When it comes to image quality, the
Interestingly, while the X5 performs admirably, the Qoocam 3 Ultra slightly outperforms it in sharpness, evident when zooming into text or intricate details. However, the X5’s advantages become clear when considering chromatic aberration and highlight handling. The Qoocam 3 Ultra exhibits some noticeable aberration, particularly in high-contrast areas, which compromises its realism.
HDR Test – Is Insta360 ’s HDR Actually HDR?
One of the major selling points of the X5 is its HDR capability at 5.7K and 60fps. However, this “HDR” feature is misleading. Upon closer inspection of the raw files, it becomes clear that the X5 still operates within 8-bit color and is not true HDR as defined by industry standards.
In comparison, the Qoocam 3 Ultra offers a true 10-bit HDR experience, allowing for richer colors and better dynamic range. While the X5 can produce decent HDR images, they fall short when viewed on platforms that support true HDR content.
Overheating & Battery Life Test – X5 vs Qoocam 3 Ultra in Heat
Heat management is crucial for any camera, especially when recording in demanding conditions. During a rigorous overheating test under the California sun, the X5 performed exceptionally well, recording for 86 minutes without overheating. In contrast, the Qoocam 3 Ultra overheated after just 27 minutes, which is a significant drawback for anyone planning to shoot extended sessions in warm environments.
Both the X4 and X5 maintained stable temperatures, with the X4 running for 70 minutes. This reliability is a key consideration for videographers who need to shoot for longer periods without interruptions.
Low-Light Comparison – Studio, Street, and Concert Testing
The X5’s low-light capabilities are one of its standout features. In controlled studio tests, it showed remarkable highlight retention and better noise performance compared to the X4 and Qoocam 3 Ultra. The AI processing in the X5 helps to maintain sharpness even in challenging lighting conditions.
However, when tested in real-world chaotic environments, such as music festivals, the X5 struggled under certain lighting conditions, particularly with blue LED lights. This resulted in unwanted digital noise around highlights, showcasing the limitations of its PureVideo AI processing.
PureVideo in a Rave – Lasers, Fog Machines, and Chaotic Lighting
The real test for the X5 came during a rave in Downtown Los Angeles. Filming under intense DMX strobe lights and lasers, the X5 managed to capture stable footage, showcasing its FlowState stabilization. Despite the chaotic environment, it performed admirably, but not without its flaws.
While the footage was stable, the AI struggled with fast lighting changes, leading to heavy banding issues. In such scenarios, switching to standard 8K mode with manual exposure provided better results, highlighting that while the PureVideo mode is impressive, it isn’t infallible.
Stabilization Showdown – Drone, Fast Motion, and Horizon Lock
Stabilization is a critical aspect of any 360 camera, especially when it comes to aerial footage. The
In comparison, the Qoocam 3 Ultra has introduced a beta feature called Visual Enhancement. This AI-driven tool attempts to stabilize the horizon during rapid changes in speed. While it is a substantial improvement, it still falls short of the X5’s capabilities. The X5’s advanced stabilization ensures the horizon remains locked, making it the go-to choice for drone enthusiasts.
Stitching Quality – Fusion Angle, Close-Up Objects, and Horizon Fixes
Stitching quality is vital in 360 video production, and the
In a side-by-side comparison, the X4 and X5 demonstrate remarkably similar stitching quality, both outperforming the Qoocam 3 Ultra. The X5’s AI stitching analyzes footage frame by frame, dynamically optimizing the stitch based on background distance. This ensures that even after moving out of the frame, the stitching recalibrates flawlessly, maintaining the integrity of the scene.
The Qoocam 3 Ultra, however, struggles with distance stitching, leading to noticeable artifacts in the final output. The
360 Photo Test – 72MP vs 96MP
When it comes to still photography, the
This 24MP bump in resolution is particularly advantageous for virtual tour creators and those focused on high-quality still images. The difference is noticeable, especially when zooming in on distant objects, such as signage or intricate details in landscapes. While the X5 produces stunning images, the Qoocam 3 Ultra is the better option for those who prioritize still photography.
InstaFrame
No
The downside? The image quality isn’t on par with what you’d get from a high-end smartphone or even other dedicated action cameras. The purpose of a 360 camera is to capture immersive footage, allowing you to “shoot first, point later.” InstaFrame essentially flips this concept, and many users may find it less useful than intended.
Bullet Time Test – Has Anything Actually Improved?
Bullet Time has long been a standout feature in the
If you’re primarily interested in Bullet Time capabilities, sticking with the X4 might be a more cost-effective choice. The X5 offers some technical improvements, but they don’t dramatically enhance the overall experience.
Design Changes
Despite the X5’s advanced features, it has managed to maintain a lightweight design, weighing only 3 grams less than the X4. This may seem minimal, but for action sports and aerial cinematography, every gram counts. In comparison, the Qoocam 3 Ultra is significantly heavier, making the X5 a more appealing option for those looking to mount the camera on drones or FPV setups.
Additionally, the X5 introduces a magnetic mounting system at its base, compatible with the Insta360 Ace Pro 2 quick-release system. This innovation allows for easier transitions between setups and encourages third-party accessory makers to develop compatible mounts. For instance, the Ulanzi system is smaller and lighter than
Audio Test – New Steel Mesh Wind Guard vs Ambient Noise
The
While the current setup is impressive, there are future plans for the X5 to support 4-channel, first-order Ambisonic audio. This upgrade could enhance the onboard spatial audio capabilities, making it a standout feature for immersive audio experiences. However, this functionality isn’t available yet, and testing remains pending.
Lens Replacement Kit – Anti-Scratch Glass and Field Repairs
One of the most talked-about upgrades in the
In the past, users often faced issues with regular lens guards that compromised image quality. The swappable lens design not only saves costs on customer support but also enhances user satisfaction. Having a backup lens means you can continue shooting without the hassle of sending your camera in for repairs.
For those upgrading from the X4, it’s worth noting that the new design eliminates the need for cumbersome lens guards. This innovation makes field repairs straightforward, ensuring you can maintain high-quality footage even after accidents.
Software Update Review – New Features in Insta360 Studio
The Insta360 Studio has received significant updates that enhance the editing experience. One of the most exciting features is the ability to preview 360 video clips directly in your file manager. This interactive player mimics what you’d see on platforms like YouTube VR, making it easier to manage large projects.
Another noteworthy addition is the Tilt Restore feature, allowing you to maintain the original tilt angle in your footage. This is particularly useful in dynamic scenarios, such as motorsports, where natural tilting occurs. The ability to preserve this tilt adds a layer of authenticity to your videos.
AI Stitching has also seen improvements with the new Stitch Fusion Angle option. This feature helps clean up close-up stitch lines, crucial when shooting unpredictable subjects. As a result, capturing intricate details becomes much more manageable, making it a valuable tool for creators.
360 Video Editing for Vision Pro – Immersive Video Export Made Easy
The most significant software update is the ability to edit immersive 360 video for Apple Vision Pro playback directly within
With this update, users can effectively cancel subscriptions to other editing software, as Insta360 Studio now covers essential editing needs for immersive content. It’s a practical solution for those who want to streamline their workflow without compromising quality.
Final Verdict – The Truth Behind the Hype
In summary, the
Despite these concerns, there is ample room for growth. The hardware improvements and higher bitrate potential suggest that future firmware updates could enhance the X5’s performance. The X-series remains a beloved choice among creators, and with further refinements, the X5 could solidify its place at the top.
FAQ
What are the main upgrades in the Insta360 X5 compared to the X4?
The X5 features a new steel mesh wind guard, fully replaceable lenses, and improved battery life. Additionally, software updates enhance editing capabilities and introduce new features like Tilt Restore and Stitch Fusion Angle.
Can I use my old X4 accessories with the X5?
No, the X5 has a different battery design and charging port location, meaning old X4 accessories won’t fit. It’s advisable to sell your X4 accessories if you’re upgrading to the X5.
Is the Insta360 Cloud necessary for editing videos?
No, while the
What is the significance of the replaceable lens design?
The replaceable lens design allows for easy repairs and replacements, reducing downtime and eliminating concerns about lens damage affecting image quality.
How do the new features in the Insta360 Studio improve the editing process?
New features like 360 video previews and Tilt Restore streamline the editing process, making it faster and more intuitive, while AI Stitching enhancements improve stitching quality in complex shots.
Add Comment